Hotter temperatures and motorcycles threaten urban air quality, says new TRUE report

Main Image
The report was covered on French national and international media.
The report was covered on French national and international media.
ICCT researcher Yoann Bernard discusses findings with the media.
ICCT researcher Yoann Bernard discusses findings with the media.
The launch was held in Paris City Hall with Sheila Watson, Yoann Bernard and Deputy Mayors Christophe Najdovski and Aurélie Solans.
The launch was held in Paris City Hall with Sheila Watson, Yoann Bernard and Deputy Mayors Christophe Najdovski and Aurélie Solans.

New data from real-world emissions testing, supported by the FIA Foundation, shows up to a 30% increase in nitrogen oxide emissions from diesel cars at higher summer temperatures and reveals motorcycle emissions of certain pollutants “greatly exceed” averages for both petrol and diesel cars.

Diesel car emissions of nitrogen oxide (NOX) skyrocket by up to 30% at ambient temperatures over 30°C, new testing shows, says The Real Urban Emissions (TRUE) Initiative, launching its report on Paris real-world vehicle emissions on 10 September at Paris City Hall with Deputy Mayors Christophe Najdovski and Aurélie Solans.

Measurements of the real-world NOX, particulate and CO2 emissions from over 180,000 vehicles - including L-category vehicles and buses – were taken at three Paris sites in summer 2018 with the support of Mayor Hidalgo’s office.

New data highlights the ongoing impact of the dieselgate scandal, and confirms real-world NOx emissions are systemically much higher from diesel cars, and that this holds true for most of the newest (Euro 6) models. The results show that the excess emissions from diesel passenger cars in particular - which previous TRUE results show produce up to 18 times EU limits – rise in higher temperatures, amplifying the severe health and environmental impacts of excess emissions.

Temperature (read the fact sheet here)

  • NOx emissions of Euro 5 and Euro 6 diesel cars measured at ambient temperatures above 30 °C were 20% to 30% higher than at temperatures between 20 and 30 °C, which is the temperature range specified in the NEDC test protocol for laboratory type-approval tests.
  • Higher temperatures increase the formation of ground-level ozone, which has serious respiratory health associations, from the reaction of NOx with other pollutants.
  • The newest Euro 6 RDE test protocol boundaries allow NOx emissions to increase by 60% between 30 and 35 °C, and above 35°C no limits to NOx emissions are defined at all.
  • Temperatures in Paris exceeded 30 ˚C on 20 days between the start of June and end of August 2019. As the effects of climate change intensify, the number of days with comparably high or higher temperatures in Europe will rise, especially in urban heat islands such as Paris.

Motorcycles and other L-category vehicles (read the fact sheet here)

  • L-category vehicle fuel-specific emissions (grams per kilogram of fuel consumed) are up to 11.1 times higher for CO emissions and 6.1 times higher for NOx emissions compared to average petrol passenger car emissions.
  • While fuel-specific emissions of CO and NOx from L-category vehicles have declined with the implementation of more stringent Euro standards, they have trailed behind passenger cars, and L-category standards only go up to Euro 4.
  • Considering vehicles only certified to current standards (Euro 4 and Euro respectively), CO emissions are almost 10 times those of both Euro 6 diesel and petrol cars, and NOx emissions are three times those of Euro 6 petrol cars.

TRUE is a partnership of the FIA Foundation, the International Council on Clean Transportation, the Global New Car Assessment Programme, Transport and Environment, and C40 Cities, which seeks to bring transparency to the public debate on vehicle emissions and urban air quality.

The data has also been incorporated into TRUE’s rating system, an innovative and interactive database which ranks light-duty vehicles on their emissions, which now has data from over 1 million vehicles across Europe.

Paris is the second pilot city to work with TRUE to assess real-world emissions challenges, following London in December 2018. Other cities will be added to the rating system in the future, to enable cities to identify their key emissions issues.

Sheila Watson, Deputy Director of the FIA Foundation, commented: “Dirty diesel vehicles have knowingly been manufactured and sold for decades and these excess emissions alone are responsible for some 38,000 deaths each year. These new results show the legacy of that deception and the growing challenges cities face. The unacceptable urban health burden caused by diesel vehicles increases as cities get hotter in terms of both the level of emissions and the health impact of those emissions. This poses huge implications for cities all around the world as we face hotter and hotter summers in a climate crisis to which transport it a major contributor. It also shows that two- and three-wheelers are neither the answer to urban air quality nor traffic issues.

It is impossible to future proof our cities without reliable real-world data upon which to base policies. That is why the FIA Foundation is delighted to support TRUE’s work, in partnership with Mayor Hidalgo, which we hope will strengthen the transport policy framework for cleaner, safer cities.”

Drew Kodjak, Executive Director of the ICCT, "The use of remote-sensing technology to measure on-road emissions from vehicles is already giving us a clearer and more detailed picture of the sources of air-quality problems in cities like Paris. It's striking to see, for example, that Euro 4 L-category vehicles, which qualify for the Crit’Air 1 emissions class, have high CO, NOx and PM emissions relative to other vehicle types that qualify for Crit’Air 1, and to realize that therefore the share of air pollution attributable to these vehicles could grow within the Paris LEZ as access restrictions are tightened in coming years. This is the kind of information that can inform how cities develop and refine policy, and ultimately how they can succeed in achieving the goal of a zero-emission transport sector."

Christophe Najdovski, Paris Deputy Mayor for transport, said: “Paris was the first French city to set up a low emission zone in 2015. The ICCT study confirms that the diesel ban is the right objective. Also we could go further to get clean air back in Paris. This is an objective that which we should all share.”

Karine Léger, Managing Director of Airparif which monitors Paris air quality, said: “The quality of the air we breathe depends on emissions, that is to say, the amount of pollutants released into the atmosphere. But there is no simple connection between the two given the influence of meteorology and atmospheric chemistry. As a result, the one-shot measurement campaign carried out by the TRUE project on a 180,000-vehicle sample in Paris provides important insights. It allows us to go further in interpreting the trends in air quality breathed in Paris with regard to emissions related to road traffic, which remains the main source of pollution in the capital.”

Coverage highlights include The Guardian, Le Monde, BFM TV, and Le Parisien